So the rest of the products I used were simple and all by Nyx save for the Maybelline Lash Stiletto mascara.
I decided to go with:
Nyx 10 Color Palette Eye Shadow The Runway Collection: 01 Jazz Night
(silver, dark grey and blue),
Nyx Mosaic Powder Blush in Paradise,
Nyx Lip Lacquer Pot in Caramel
* Notice I didn't use any primer at all and the colors worked out well. They also lasted at least 8 hours. I will check out the Nyx Eyeshadow Base soon to see how it compares to my Urban Decay Primer Potion.
Now my Cheap Face Challenge wasn't just about the make-up. I also wanted to use cheap brushes. I used my Shany 12-piece brush set for this. They performed very well but the set has one major flaw: no blending brush. I ended up using my Nyx Contoured Dome Brush because it's cheap and awesome.